HOW MUCH IS THE UK COMIC INDUSTRY WORTH?
in 2011, Dundee Univeristy launched its Comic Studies degree,
akin to other courses it offered in gaming at Abertay which have helped people
get jobs in that industry. There was some debate about the value of the degree,
prompted by remarks by Scottish Labour MP Tom Harris on Twitter (see
news story). The debate also prompted to re-visit this page and update
it, not just in terms of sales figures but also pose the question - how much
is the comics industry worth in the UK (and elsewhere)?
Strangely, although it's easy to find figures indicating
the value of other media industries - gaming, music, film, animation for example
- the revenues genrated by the UK comics industry in terms of employment, sales
and related merchadise and tie-in product (films, TV and comic-inspired games,
for example) are hard to quantify and ascertain.
Although news stand and direct sales of print comics are
in decline in many traditional markets (not just the UK but US, Europe etc)
they do appear to be increasing in many developing countries with large, and
young, populations and therefore huge potential markets. Collections and graphic
album sales remain bouyant and the comics form continues to thrive online,
and digital sales of comics - for PCs, iPad, Kindle and other devices - are
a new factor in a complex equation.
UK
COMIC SALES FIGURES
UK news stand comics these days are generally reprint-led,
licensed titles, but sales are strong and in the past couple of years the amount
of original material in these is growing (Ben
10 and Transformers being
examples of blending some new strips with previously published material, a
key feature of the early 1980s/1990s licensed titles published by Marvel UK).
Sales vary and are a far cry from the
huge sales of the 1960s and 1970s. I
have compiled some sales based on ABC registered figures a while back and
here's a link to the results. (Advertisers
can also consult British
Rate and Data, which publishes information on ABC-listed sales for
all magazines in the UK, including comics).
Pre-school and humour comics
remain the top sellers: DC Thomson's weekly Beano and Dandy titles
still do well, although The Dandy's 2011 revamp did not appear to
re-ignite interest in any major way. Titan's Simpsons
Comics and Egmont's Ben 10 sell over 70,000 copies an issue. Egmont
Fleetway have had ongoing success with TOXIC!,
a predominantly feature-led boys' title which now includes several strip
pages.
Estimated sales
on the last remaining originated weekly adventure comic not based on licensed
properties, 2000AD, vary
wildly but are belived to be lower than 20,000, despite the continued
efforts by publishers Rebellion to promote the title beyond their regular readership.
UK PART WORK SALES
In recent
years, part
work publishers have launched a number of comic strip-led part works,
such as Horrible Histories and Jackie
Chan Adventures. I do not have sales figures for these but part works
companies enjoy high sales for these "collectable magazines", which
launch with a major promotional campaign and quickly go firm sale only, aiming
to achive a high subscription-based readership to ensure continued publication.
Most part works are however usually only published for about two years before
cancellation.
UK SMALL PRESS SALES
The UK has an energetic and
enthusiastic small press, which has exploded with the arrival of print technologies
that enable home printing using colour or black and white laser printing. Small
print runs are now also more economincally viable than they were in the past,
thanks to digital printing.
Small press sales vary: I would advise anyone thinking
about this to print a small number, like Selina Lock and Jay Eales do with The
Girly Comic and Violent, then
reprint to order. These two talented editors print 50 copies at a time of
their comics, using their own laser printer which cost about £800 to
buy.
Printing, say, 500 copies of an A5 fanzine with a colour
cover could cost you about £1200 (in 2005). My advice would be to consider
such an outlay very carefully unless you know you already have comic shops
who will sell copies or have some other means of distribution. And always get
more than one quote!
I would say small press publishers should recognise that
producing fanzines is unlikely to make them rich, but the fun of doing it and
the chance to promote your work in a published magazine can help you get professional
work. It worked for me when I published SCAN back
in the 1980s.
US Comic Books are also sold in the UK: these days largely
only in specialist shops such as Forbidden Planet, Gosh, Comics Showcase and
others. There are now only 110 comic shops in the UK. The sales of US comic
books in newsagents is low, but Panini and Titan Magazines publish
US-size reprints. Although WH Smiths threatened to stop stocking these titles
in 2004 they continue to sell well enough to have good distribution through
the chain.
Supermarkets sell an increasing
numbers of comics alongside other magazines but because of limited shelf space
they do not sell a wide rannge of titles. Being stocked by Tescos or Sainsbury's
can, literally, be make or break for some comics titles. I've been told by
more than one publisher that once a supermarket decides to drop a title, it
is very hard to get re-listed.
FURTHER INFORMATION ABOUT UK COMIC
SALES
If you want to know
more about comics sales, you could try asking the publishers (although they
are often cagey about releasing such information). Addresses can be found in The
Writers and Artists Year Book. I have published a number of publisher
addresses on my site: click
here for the list.
You might also be able to extrapolate the success of a company's
comics from its accounts, which are available from Companies House.
INTERNATIONAL COMIC SALES
There are some useful facts
about comics sales on, of all things, a gospel web site. Christian
Comics International. Despite the source (the
site is run by COMIX35
/ ROX35 Media, Inc., a non-profit, nondenominational ministry which
has been organised for international Christian comics training) there's some
useful facts and figures to throw at people who say comics are dead, although
the site includes a note advising that these pages have not been updated
recently.
• Worldwide and general Comics Facts and Figures - General Introduction
• Comics in Multiple Countries and Multiple Languages
THE AMERICAS
• Christian
Comics International: American Facts and Figures
Including Brazil, Colombia, Canada, Greenland, Mexico, United States, and
the Americas in general.
• Comics Chronicles
This brilliant resource carries historical data on comics sales in the US as
far back as the 1960s. It is slowly adding data for the 1970s etc. and has
a lively discussion forum
• Marvel and DC Comics Sales Figures
Comics are a business and are driven by comic sales. Actually, that's not quite
true. Comics are driven by merchandising and marketing, but comic sales still
matter. This page looks at overall sales for Marvel and DC, the two biggest
US comic companies, and the historical reasons for sales going up and down,
and how they could sell more comics today.
ASIA AND THE FAR EAST
General Information: Christian
Comics International: Asia Pacific (General)
Australia
See: Christian
Comics International: Australia
Burma
See: Christian
Comics International: Burma
Cambodia
See: Christian
Comics International: Cambodia
China
More Info: Christian
Comics International: China
(including Hong Kong and Taiwan)
India
The Indian comic industry saw a decline in sale and readership
from around the mid 1990's to early 2004 but now the major publishers of comic
books in the country are hoping for better days.
Sales per issue went down from
500,000 to almost 50,000-60,000 but are now again witnessing an upward trend
according
to Raj Comics owner, Manoj Gupta.
As in the US and UK, the Indian market is benefiting from
digital sales which are developing fast.
Today's Indian Comic Culture: www.accu.or.jp/appreb/09/pdf34-1/34-1P006-007.pdf (PDF)
More Info: Christian
Comics International: India
Indonesia
See: Christian
Comics International: Indonesia
Japan
In Japan, manga still sells well, contributing some
Y418.7 billion total in 2009 butthe Anime
News Network reported that magazine
sales fell below Y200 billion for 1st time in 18 years.
In particular, sales of manga magazines fell 9.4% to 191.3 billion yen (US$2.12
billion). Manga magazines sales had not been below the 200-billion-yen mark
in at least 18 years. Sales of print manga overall peaked in 1995.
Mobile phone sales of electronic books, including
manga, grew 331.3% from 1.6 billion yen (about $14 million) to 6.9 billion
yen ($58 million) in 2006. The Digital Content Association that reported
in 2007 that the results expected sales to reach $100 million by year end.
More info: Christian
Comics International: Japan
Malaysia
See: Christian
Comics International: Malaysia
Papua New Guinea
See: Christian
Comics International: Papua
New Guinea
The Phillipines
See: Christian
Comics International: The
Phillipines
Singapore
See: Christian
Comics International: Singapore
South Korea
See: Christian
Comics International: South
Korea
• Christian
Comics International: Thailand
EUROPE
• Christian
Comics International: European
Facts and Figures
Including Albania, Belgium, Bosnia, Croatia, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany,
Italy, Kosovo,
Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, the UK and Yugoslavia.
Norway
• The
Norwegian Comics Market
This feature on downthetubes about the 2003 Raptus event in Bergen includes
observations on comic sales
• In 2005 the new Asterix album Le
ciel lui tombe sur la tete, sold 800.000 copies in French in France and in Belgium the first three
days of its launch according to the publisher as reported in www.actuabd.com.
• This 2006
round table discussion on the Forbidden Planet International blog focuses
on UK comic sales. Participants were Dez Skinn of Comics International, Barry ‘Baz’ Renshaw
of Engine Comics‘ journal Redeye, Rich Johnston of CBR’s Lying
in the Gutters, Matthew Badham of Bugpowder and John Freeman of Down the Tubes.
THE MIDDLE EAST
• Christian
Comics International: Middle
East and Africa
Including Bahrain, Egypt, Iraq, Kuwait, Lebanon, Mozambique, Oman, Pakistan,
Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, South Africa, Syria, Tanzania, Tunisia, Turkey,
and the United Arab Emirates
WHO READS COMICS?
What is the sex and average age of people reading mainstream comics, graphic novels, and comics strips in newspapers?
I don't think it's any big secret that, excluding pre-school readers, the vast majority of comics readers are male. UK comics are aimed at children with different titles for different age groups. There are very few comics aimed specifically at teenagers today -- sadly, 2000AD is the last of the kind of boys adventure title I grew up reading.
Football comic Striker was cancelled in May 2005 after sales fell below 20,000. There are no teenage girl comics to speak of these days that have a wide distribution.
The only exception to this is the readership of manga, primarily distributed in the UK by Tokyopop. Many titles have a large female following and, just as the original material is created by many Japanese women, female UK manga fans happily create their won small press titles, often sold at anime rather than comics conventions.
The age range of comics readers buying comics in comic shops
varies but I would say it's teenager upwards with the real "hardcore" US
comics fans in their late 20s and up -- the generation who has easy access
to such material (late thirties and 40s) are probably the most regular and
committed comics buyers.
Graphic novels are now sold widely and depending on
press coverage on release, some will reach beyond the readership of regular
comics readers.. Titles such as Fungus the Bogeyman and
other Raymond Briggs books have huge readerships as do books using comic strip
to enhance their own naratuve, such as Terry Deary's Horrible
Histories (a
series which has also been published as a comic-led part part work). Compilations
of newspaper strips such as Steve Bell's If from
the Guardian will have a wider readership,
too. Titan Books have published graphic novels for over 20 years with continued
success, recently publishing a number of newspaper strip collections such as
Modesty Blaise and James Bond.
Comic strips are also published in several newspapers. The
Mirror and The Sun still
publish almost a full page of strips, but the number of strips is nowhere near
as large of diverse as the number published via syndication in US or European
papers.
What is the proportion of comics dedicated to a new readership?
Very few. As of June 2011, none of the major UK publishers
whose magazine titles sell enormous numbers -- such as Emap, IPC, Haymarket
-- have any plans to publish comics. The bottom line is that when you can
publish a magazine title and sell, say 700,000 copies, there is no commercial
sense (as far as these publishers are concerned) in publishing a comic that
would sell perhaps 100,000 copies (based on the data they all have access
to for comics sales, see above) and make a tenth of the profit.
Even if they
did decided to publish comics tomorrow, it would still require editors and
staff to be recruited for a new department, perhaps, and freelancers sourced,
which for a large publisher could take between 18 months to two years.
On top of that, launching any title into the British
news trade is costly. Retailers charge publishers to get their titles on
their shelves and the cost of that for a new title could be anything between £18,000
to £25,000 (and up!). That's even before your marketing campaign,
which could cost as little as £25,000 but is usually much, much higher.
It should therefore be obvious that publishers are not going to be enthusiastic
about launching a title which, as far as they can see, will not have the
sales potential of their hugely successful magazines.
This is one reason why
many comics titles feature reprint material from the US or elsewhere, in order
to minimise editorial costs.
Are comics and graphic novels are enjoying a greater level of acceptance than previously?
Graphic novels are certainly getting a lot more shelf space
than they used to -- which is good news. Certainly in the US many books are
getting plenty of exposure in the mainstream press -- not often afforded them
here in the UK, though! You can check www.icv2.com,
a US reatlers news site, which runs news items on mentions for graphic novels
in the New York Times and the like.
Are they more accepted? Hmm. I still think
there's a lot of snobbery about comics from certain quarters in the UK which
you don't find on the continent or in countries like Japan or the US. There
still seems to be a prevailing attitude that comics are for kids, not adults,
despite the work of writers like Alan Moore, Neil Gaiman, Grant Morrison and
many other UK creators.
Are more people reading graphic novels?
Yes -- more people do seem to be reading graphic novels than the comics that
spawned them, i.e. they are buying collections of many comics, as well as original graphic
novels. Manga is now extremely popular in the UK, just as it is in the US and the continent.
Are more older people reading graphic novels?
I think more adults read graphic novels, probably because
they grew up with comics whereas today's youngsters haven't, because there
are no weekly comics as there were until the early 1990s. Yes, there are plenty
of comics out there (see above) but most are either aimed at the pre-school
of very young and anything aimed at teenagers -- 2000AD,
the Panini reprints of superheroes, Titan's
Batman Adventures and Star
Wars Comic -- do not have the huge readerships of
the past.
James Hill, who was Editor in Chief at the now defunct Oldham-based
comics company Toontastic feels that in part this is because youngsters today
are getting their narrative from other sources -- TV, the web, games, music
videos -- and comics can't compete.
I think it's also down to the fact that
most youngsters don't know what comics are any more -- certainly not adventure
comics, anyway. Jason Kingsley, owner of 2000AD,
once told me they were doing a promotion at a skateboard event one time and
a teenager picked up one of the freebies and started to flick through it. The
conversation went something like this:
"What's this?"
"It's a comic."
"Cool... what's a comic?"
"It's a magazine that tells stories with words and pictures. The story's
told using speech balloons, see--"
"What a brilliant idea! Who thought of that! It's really cool!"
So, not only are publishers trying to sell comics to people who know what
they are and convince them they're comic is worth buying, they've also got
a hard slog actually selling comics as a medium by all accounts -- certainly
to the teenage audience who would be the most likely to buy them and make them
hip. Not that this can't be done, but when the PR budgets of most comics companies
is a fraction of what Nike or Sony can throw into an advertising campaign,
you can see comics publishers have their work cut out for them.
Of course, comics
isn't just about the ones you buy -- as culture, comics creators have taken
to the web like ducks to water and there's a tremendous amount of talent out
there with a worldwide reach they would never have got simply publishing a
fanzine sold to comics fans at a Comic Mart or, if they're lucky, in their
local comic shop. That's a very exciting aspect of comics storytelling right
now, and you can create comics in many different ways on the web without losing
sight of the fact that they're comics. The UK small press is increasingly gathering
strength and confidence, despite smaller sales than titles that do make it
to the news stand.
One of my readers Jonathan Clegg asked me if I thought that critics have begun to embrace the comic or graphic
novel as a legitimate form? "I know that critics fell all over themselves to
praise the work of Chris Ware and Joe Sacco, and Paul Auster's work," he asked, "but is this indicative of a wider critical acceptance
from people who wouldn't previously have considered the comic book a
worthwhile medium?
No -- I still think there's a lot of snobbery about comics from the
"critics". They should listen to Phillip Pullman and stop being so snooty.
"And if either of these things are true, then why?" Jonathan asked. "Do you think that comics
and graphic novels have changed substantially over the past decade? Have
they been affected by changes in, for instance, film and TV?
Comics are a different form of storytelling to film and tv and they have an
entirely different way of presenting narrative. Someone - I think it was
Will Eisner --once said that comics storytelling is about the space between the
frame not just the frames themselves. Yes, a lot of comics creators have
borrowed heavily from film and tv storytelling but to me this slows down the
storytelling whereas comics can be sequential without tracking a character's
actions from the moment he walks out his front door to the moment he walks
into a bar, as you might with a film. You can jump from a character walking
out of his house straight to the bar and if he's with someone, they can
still be having the same conversation. I'd recommend looking at Frank
Miller's Daredevil or Eisner's comics storytelling books to understand what
I mean by this if you're intrigued.
Jonathan Clegg again: "I recently read Stan Lee's foreword in the re-issue of Marvels, and he said
that, looking back on the book, he thought it marked a point at which
comics began to focus on more mature, human stories. Do you think they have
done this? And if so, who is responsible?"
Comics have always been about human stories. In some ways, the move in
superhero comics to this kind of storytelling has taken all the fun out of
the genre, something Alan Moore recognised when he started the ABC Comics
line and started having fun with Tom Strong.
A French comics creator will find this train of thought very odd of course,
because there have always been "adult" comics on the continent -- as well as
those strips British people recognise such as Tin Tin and Asterix.
Jonathan Clegg again: "What accounts for what I'd call the 'hipness' of comics nowadays? By which
I mean that comics seem to be everywhere - from the latest hot American
teen sitcom, The OC, to Michael Chabon's award winning novel, The Amazing
Adventure of Kavalier and Clay, to a whole host of comic book movies
hitting the big screen (The Fantastic Four for example, but also less
well-known titles like American Splendor, Ghost World and Hellboy) - what's
driving this?"
The simple answer -- the people who are making these shows
grew up with comics and want them in there, somehow! As for the films -- the
honest answer is that film companies recognise a "brand" like Superman
or the X-Men as a potentially big box office draw and want to exploit that.
Modern visual effects have finally caught up with what superheroes could only
do in comic books, and so you're seeing more superheroes -- even ones that
have never appeared in comics like Columbia's recently-announced Tonight,
He Comes, a dark superhero tale written by Vincent Ngo, wich will star Will
Smith.
This has happened before -- don't forget comics in the US
didn't use to be just about superheroes. You had romance comics, horror comics
(until they were banned and then gutted by the censors), westerns... as soon
as TV and film started making those kind of stories, the comics seem to have
started to suffer -- although of course comics publishers have also published
comics in response to film and tv.
